Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings

Menupickcom

Pusateri's Chicago Pizza menu

20 dishes across 5 sections $10 to $20 Pizza restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu Pusateri's Chicago Pizza photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

Start Here, Pizzas! 4 dishes

  • Personal Pizza US$8.55

  • Small Cheese US$13.75

    Good enough to stand alone, along with the tastiest crust and sauce

  • Medium Cheese Pizza US$19.75

    Good enough to stand alone, along with the tastiest crust and sauce

  • Large Cheese US$23.50

    Good enough to stand alone, along with the tastiest crust and sauce

Gluten Free Pizzas 2 dishes

  • Cauliflower Pizza US$15.95

  • Gluten Free US$13.50

Small Gourmet Pizza 11 dishes

  • Small Chicken Alfredo US$15.65

    Best with chicken! But your favorite topping will also taste awesome. (Extra topping charge)

  • Small BBQ Chicken US$18.80

    BBQ sauce base with a small blend of pizza sauce, topped with moist chicken strips and red onion. Add any topping for more flavor

  • Small Chicago Fire. US$21.35

    This is for the people who love hot and spicy. Meatballs, thin sliced Italian roast beef, hot giardiniera and a sport pepper garnish

  • Small Hawaiian US$17.25

    Generously layered with sliced ham and dole pineapple tidbits

  • Small John Hancock US$23.25

    6 whopping toppings! Signature sausage, pepperoni, red/green peppers, mushrooms, onion, and black olives

  • Small JP's Sauceless Spinach and Mushroom US$17.50

    No red sauce. Garlic cream base, blended cheese, spinach and sliced mushrooms. *Adding sausage makes this pizza amazing! (Extra topping charge)

  • Small Magnificent Meat US$21.35

    Our all meat special! Signature sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, and ham

  • Small Very Veggie US$21.35

    Everything fresh and only the best! We start with fresh leaf spinach, mushrooms, green bell peppers, sliced red tomatoes, chopped onions, and garlic

  • Small White Pizza US$15.65

  • Small Signature Sausage US$15.65

  • Small Margherita US$16.50

Medium Gourmet Pizza 11 dishes

  • Medium Chicken Alfredo US$22.20

    Best with chicken! But your favorite topping will also taste awesome. (Extra topping charge)

  • Medium Very Veggie US$29.45

    Everything fresh and only the best! We start with fresh leaf spinach, mushrooms, green bell peppers, sliced red tomatoes, chopped onions, and garlic

  • Medium John Hancock US$31.85

    6 whopping toppings! Signature sausage, pepperoni, red/green peppers, mushrooms, onion, and black olives

  • Medium Magnificent Meat US$29.45

    Our all meat special! Signature sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, and ham

  • Medium Chicago Fire US$29.45

    This is for the people who love hot and spicy. Meatballs, thin sliced Italian roast beef, hot giardiniera and a sport pepper garnish

  • Medium JP's Sauceless Spinach and Mushroom US$24.60

    No red sauce. Garlic cream base, blended cheese, spinach and sliced mushrooms. *Adding sausage makes this pizza amazing! (Extra topping charge)

  • Medium BBQ Chicken US$25.90

    BBQ sauce base with a small blend of pizza sauce, topped with moist chicken strips and red onion. Add any topping for more flavor

  • Medium Hawaiian US$24.60

    Generously layered with sliced ham and dole pineapple tidbits

  • Medium White Pizza US$22.20

  • Medium Signature Sausage US$22.20

  • Medium Margherita US$23.50

Large Gourmet Pizza 10 dishes

  • Large Chicken Alfredo US$26.30

    Best with chicken! But your favorite topping will also taste awesome. (Extra topping charge)

  • Large BBQ Chicken US$30.50

    BBQ sauce base with a small blend of pizza sauce, topped with moist chicken strips and red onion. Add any topping for more flavor

  • Large Chicago Fire. US$35.00

    This is for the people who love hot and spicy. Meatballs, thin sliced Italian roast beef, hot giardiniera and a sport pepper garnish

  • Large Hawaiian US$29.25

    Generously layered with sliced ham and dole pineapple tidbits

  • Large John Hancock US$37.90

    6 whopping toppings! Signature sausage, pepperoni, red/green peppers, mushrooms, onion, and black olives

  • Large JP's Sauceless Spinach and Mushroom US$29.25

    No red sauce. Garlic cream base, blended cheese, spinach and sliced mushrooms. *Adding sausage makes this pizza amazing! (Extra topping charge)

  • Large Magnificent Meat US$35.00

    Our all meat special! Signature sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, and ham

  • Large Very Veggie US$35.00

    Everything fresh and only the best! We start with fresh leaf spinach, mushrooms, green bell peppers, sliced red tomatoes, chopped onions, and garlic

  • Large White Pizza US$26.30

  • Large Signature Sausage US$26.30

Chicago Hot Dogs 3 dishes

  • Chicago-Style Dog US$6.00

    Comes with any or all of the following choices piled on a steamed poppy seed bun: yellow mustard, the famous "Bright green relish", fresh chopped onion, two tomato wedges, a dill pickle spear, two sport peppers, and a dash of celery salt

  • Plain Vienna® Dog US$5.50

    The bare dog and bun

  • "The Windy City" Combo US$8.50

    Chicago-style hot dog, soft drink, and a bag of chips

"The Windy City" Combo 1 dishes

  • "The Windy City" Combo US$8.50

    Chicago-style hot dog, soft drink, and a bag of chips

Appetizers 17 dishes

  • Pusateri's Bread US$6.25

    Gimme garlic with cheese topped with sliced tomatoes and your choice of hot or mild giardiniera

  • Gimme Garlic Bread US$4.35

    8 pieces. You asked for it, you got it! Crispy and buttery garlic on the most awesome bread

  • Gimme Garlic with Cheese US$5.50

    You asked for it, you got it! Crispy, buttery garlic on the most awesome bread.

  • Fried Raviolis US$10.00

  • Onion Rings US$8.75

  • Golden Battered Mushrooms US$10.00

  • 4 Chicken Tenders And Fries US$12.00

  • Battered Zucchini Sticks US$8.75

  • Mozzarella Sticks (10 pcs) US$10.00

    10 Mozzarella sticks per order.

  • State Street Combo Basket US$12.50

  • French Fries US$3.75

  • Garlic Parmesan French Fries US$5.50

  • Wings (8) US$12.50

    Six Chicken Wings fried. Toss in a sauce of your choice or get them plain with sauce on the side!

  • Meatballs (3) US$5.75

  • Meatballs (2) US$3.75

  • Cheese Fries US$5.75

  • Jalapeno Poppers (8) US$10.00

Hot Sandwiches 6 dishes

  • Italian Beef Sandwich US$10.00

    Hot Italian roast beef thinly sliced and served on bread soaked in seasoned au jus

  • Sausage Sandwich US$10.50

    Only at Pusateri's will you find this one!

  • Chi-Town Combo US$12.50

    The best of both worlds. Our famous sausage flat-style, with hot Italian roast beef piled on top. Comes one way, with just a dash of red sauce and au jus drippings from the seasoned beef. This one satisfies the biggest appetite!

  • Classic Meatball & Cheese Sub US$10.50

    Three meatballs seasoned with a special recipe then topped with our marinara sauce

  • Chicken Parm Sub US$10.50

  • Eggplant Parm Sandwich US$12.50

Wings and Side 2 dishes

  • Wings (8) US$12.50

  • Wings (12 ) US$15.50

Hot Dogs 4 dishes

  • Chicago-Style Dog US$6.00

    Comes with any or all of the following choices piled on a steamed poppy seed bun: yellow mustard, the famous "Bright green relish", fresh chopped onion, two tomato wedges, a dill pickle spear, two sport peppers, and a dash of celery salt

  • Plain Vienna® Dog US$5.50

    The bare dog and bun

  • vienna hot dogs 10 count US$22.98

  • vienna hot dog buns 10 count US$11.50

Salads 4 dishes

  • House Salad US$0.00

    Iceberg/romaine mix, tomato, cucumber, carrot sticks, cheese, and red onion

  • Classic Caesar US$0.00

    Romaine lettuce, croûtons, Parmesan cheese, and Caesar dressing

  • Antipasto US$12.50

    Iceberg/romaine mix, pepperoni, ham, salami, provolone cheese, tomato, cucumber, carrot sticks, black olives, and pepperoncinis

  • Caprese Salad US$12.00

BYO Pasta Dinners 1 dishes

  • Build Your Own Dinner US$17.25

Baked Dinners 4 dishes

  • Baked Ziti US$18.25

    Penne topped with ricotta cheese and marinara and baked with mozzarella cheese

  • Baked Spaghetti US$18.25

    Spaghetti tossed in marinara and baked with mozzarella cheese

  • Eggplant Parmigiana US$20.75

    Crispy Eggplant on top a bed of Spaghetti with Ricotta and Marinara sauce baked with Mozzarella Cheese and topped with Parmesan and Basil

  • Chicken Parmigiana US$20.75

    Crispy Chicken on top of spaghetti, baked to perfection with Mozzarella Cheese

Kids Menu 4 dishes

  • Personal Pan Pizza US$8.55

  • Kids Pasta with Garlic Bread US$8.55

  • Chicken Tenders & French Fries (2 pcs Chicken) US$8.55

    3 Chicken fingers served with french fries.

  • Meatballs (3) US$5.75

Desserts 12 dishes

  • Cannoli US$5.00

    locally and freshly baked daily. First come first serve availability.

  • Tiramisu US$5.50

  • Pumpkin Cheesecake US$5.00

  • Seasonal - Limoncello Mascarpone Cake US$6.00

  • Large Cookie - Smores US$5.00

    We are proud to offer Delany's Delights an assortment or fresh home extra large baked Cookies ,

  • Large Cookie- Brownie Kit Kat US$5.00

  • Large Cookie- Lemon Creme US$5.00

  • Large Cookie - Red Velvet US$5.00

  • Large Cookie - Chocolate Chip US$5.00

  • Large Cookie - Strawberry Shortcake US$5.00

  • Large Cookie - Scoff US$5.00

  • Large Cookie - Monster Cookie US$5.00

Extras 23 dishes

  • Bag of Chips US$1.45

  • Black olives-2 oz US$1.45

  • Extra Caesar US$0.50

  • Extra Au Jus US$1.10

  • Extra Balsamic US$0.50

  • Extra Beef US$4.00

  • Extra Bleu Chz US$0.50

  • Extra Honey Mustard US$0.50

  • Extra Italian US$0.50

  • Extra Marinara US$2.00

  • Extra Ranch US$0.50

  • Extra Sausage US$4.00

  • Marinara US$1.10

  • Meatball Side with Sauce US$5.75

    3 meatballs

  • Mozzarella Cheese US$1.25

  • Pepporcini US$1.45

  • Provolone Cheese US$1.25

  • Ricotta Cheese US$1.25

  • Sautéed Mushrooms US$1.45

  • Sautéed Onions US$1.45

  • Side Hot Giardiniera US$1.45

  • Side Mild Giardiniera US$1.45

  • Sweet Green Peppers US$1.45

Catering 15 dishes

  • sausage per pound US$11.50

  • sliced italian beef per pound US$17.23

  • Hoagie rolls 6 count US$11.50

  • vienna hot dogs 10 count US$22.98

  • vienna hot dog buns 10 count US$11.50

  • house salad 1/2 pan (feeds 5) US$25.00

  • house salad full pan (feeds 10) US$45.00

  • caesar 1/2 pan (feeds 5) US$30.00

  • caesar full pan (feeds 10) US$50.00

  • anitpasto 1/2 (feeds 5) US$35.00

  • antipasto full pan (feeds 10) US$75.00

  • spaghetti w/marinara 1/2 pan US$69.00

  • spaghetti w/marinara full pan US$138.00

  • baked ziti 1/2 pan US$69.00

  • baked ziti full pan US$138.00

Bottle of Giardiniera 4 dishes

  • Bottle of Hot Giardiniera US$10.99

  • Bottle of Mild Giardiniera US$10.99

  • Green Relish US$10.99

  • sport peppers US$12.99

N/A Beverages (Copy) 22 dishes

  • Apple Juice US$2.49

  • Arnold Palmer US$2.85

  • Can Ginger Ale US$2.85

  • Can Pepsi US$2.85

  • Diet Pepsi US$2.85

  • Dr Pepper US$2.85

  • Bottled Water US$1.49

  • Fountain Water US$0.00

  • Lemonade US$2.85

  • Mountain Dew US$2.85

  • Sunny D US$1.95

  • Pepsi US$2.85

  • Root Beer US$2.85

  • San Pellegrino US$3.35

  • Starry Mist US$2.85

  • Sweet Tea US$2.85

  • Unsweet Tea US$2.85

  • Water US$0.00

  • Diet Pepsi 2Ltr US$4.89

  • Starry Mist 2 Ltr US$4.89

  • can starry US$3.03

  • Simply Orange Juice Bottle US$3.00

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

Other menus in Stuart

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All Stuart listings
Call Menu Directions